Choosing a rug is about more than looks, it’s about how a piece feels in your space and how well it holds up over time. Revival Rugs and West Elm are trusted home decor brands, but when it comes to rugs, they take different approaches to design and craftsmanship.

If you’re deciding between the two, this guide breaks down the differences so you can choose the rug brand that best fits your home, lifestyle, and priorities.

Revival Rugs vs. West Elm Rugs: Side-by-Side Comparison

Different approaches to rug-making

Taiyo, Revival Rugs' washable hand-knotted wool rug

Revival Rugs

Revival Rugs is a rug-first brand, built around a deep respect for craftsmanship and material integrity. Revival Rugs offers a mix of new and restored vintage rugs, many of which are handwoven using traditional techniques passed down through generations. Each piece is chosen—or designed—with durability and longevity in mind.

West Elm

West Elm is a large-scale furniture and home retailer offering everything from sofas, to lighting, to rugs. Their rug assortment focuses on trendy designs that complement their broader collections, with an emphasis on scale.

Craftsmanship & Construction

One of the biggest differences between Revival Rugs and West Elm lies in how their rugs are made.

Revival Rugs: behind-the-scenes look at rug weaving

Revival Rugs: largely handwoven or hand-finished by skilled weavers using time-honored techniques. These rugs feature subtle variations in weave or color—details that speak to the human hands behind them that give each piece character.

West Elm: most often machine-made or tufted, designed for uniformity and large-scale production. This approach ensures products are replicable and in stock, but it tends to result in a more standardized look and feel.

Key takeaway: Revival Rugs specializes in traditional rug-making and weaving innovation; West Elm operates more broadly, prioritizing product variety and scalability

Materials & Feel Underfoot

Revival Rugs designs pieces that are woven using eco-friendly fibers like jute, wool, recycled denim, and recycled polyester. 

• Jute is a carbon-neutral crop that consumes large quantities of carbon dioxide
  
  
• Wool is a durable natural fiber that gets softer over time (and after each wash)
  
  
• Recycled denim and polyester are diverted from landfill, given a new life as rugs

Up-close look at thick wool pile of Revival Rugs' one-of-a-kind rug

Revival Rugs: vintage textiles are a sustainable alternative to buying new. The team carefully selects and restores these heritage textiles which add depth and character that can’t be replicated.  

West Elm: use a mix of materials, including wool blends, viscose, polyester, and performance fibers. Depending on the collection, this can result in a softer initial feel or easier maintenance, though longevity can vary by material.

For customers who care about how a rug feels underfoot day after day, Revival Rugs’ natural fibers and traditional construction often make a noticeable difference over time.

Design & Aesthetic

Revival Rugs: Ombre Collection, thick wool rugs in a subtle gradient

Revival Rugs: leans into timeless, design-forward, and tonal color palettes. Plus, their new and vintage one-of-a-kind rugs are handwoven pieces that are truly one of one—so there’s an option for every household.

West Elm: pieces are less memorable, often getting lost or failing to anchor a space. These designs are well-suited for spaces where rugs aren’t the primary focus.

If you’re drawn to pieces that tell a story, are textural, and woven with thoughtfully-sourced materials, Revival Rugs’ approach may resonate more.

Sustainability & Ethics

Revival Rugs' Halo Collection: freshly dyed cotton warp laid to dry

Revival Rugs: integrates sustainability into its sourcing and production by working in small batches, repurposing vintage rugs, and partnering with established weaving communities. This approach reduces waste and supports traditional craft practices.

West Elm: focuses on large-scale sustainability initiatives across its supply chain, seeking to improve standards at scale across many product categories.

Both brands engage in responsible practices, but they do so at very different levels of production and scale.

Price & Long-Term Value

Revival Rugs' timeless Dandelion easy care rug

West Elm: often comes in at a lower entry price, especially during promotional periods. This makes them appealing for quick updates or trend-based decorating, but they often lack the material and structural quality needed for longevity or high-traffic areas.

Revival Rugs: requires a higher upfront investment, particularly for vintage or handwoven pieces. However, their durability, timeless design, and craftsmanship often translate into longer life spans—meaning fewer replacements over time.

Rather than cost alone, the real comparison is short-term affordability (West Elm) versus long-term value (Revival Rugs).

Who Each Brand Is Best For

Sybil, Revival Rugs' family-friendly washable wool rug 

Choose West Elm rugs if you:

• Want a trendy piece at a lower initial price
  
  
• Prefer matching decor with furniture
  
  
• Enjoy refreshing your space seasonally
  
  
• Prioritize convenience and availability
  

Choose Revival Rugs if you:

• Value craftsmanship and traditional techniques
  
  
• Want a rug with character, history, or subtle variation
  
  
• Prefer timeless design over short-lived trends
  
  
• See rugs as long-term pieces in your home

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Revival Rugs’ pieces higher quality than West Elm’s?
Quality depends on what you value. Revival Rugs emphasizes handwoven construction and natural materials, while West Elm focuses on accessibility and consistency at scale.

Does West Elm sell handmade rugs?
Some West Elm rugs are hand-tufted or Fair Trade–certified, though most are produced using larger-scale manufacturing methods.

Is Revival Rugs worth the price?
For customers seeking durability, authenticity, and long-term use, many find Revival Rugs’ products offer strong value over time.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to rugs, the right choice depends on your lifestyle, how long you plan to keep a piece, and what matters most to you—craftsmanship, convenience, or cost.

If you’re looking for a rug that feels considered, storied, and built to last, Revival Rugs may be the right fit. If you’re refreshing a space quickly or leaning into a specific trend, West Elm offers approachable options that make decorating easy.

Explore Revival Rugs’ collections to find a rug that feels intentional, personal, and truly at home in your space. 

SHOP NOW